HW: Drummers list
Stephen Swann
swann at ST-CANARD.SPC.EDU
Fri Dec 19 10:45:19 EST 1997
Andrew A. Apold writes:
>
> 7. Danny Thompson - Chronicles & LC used to be my favorite HW albums until
> someone mentioned not liking the drumming, when I listened to it next
> I paid attention to it and this almost has ruined the album for me.
> I still like it for other reasons, but there are times when it almost
> seems Huw is having to cover for DT just to give the song some more
> rhythym. And Elric the Enchanter (part 1, from the studio version),
> once one of my favorite songs, gets me cringing, I have to force myself
> not to pay attention to the drums... also Needle Gun, that's another.
> which is why I'm waiting with baited breath to hear it done by a
> real drummer, Albert....
Oddly enough, although I abuse DT a lot, his drumming seems decent
enough to me on _LC_. Maybe it's because he's pushed way down in the
mix, unlike on Xenon Codex where that whoppingly loud THWAK THWAK
THWAK is mixed up-front and center...argh. Or maybe it's because he
"covers" other drummers' material perfectly well, but just can't come
up with his own?
DT's drumming was the *first* thing I noticed when I bought XC and
started playing _The War I Survived_. I eventually got somewhat over
my distaste for the drumming... on the Hawkwind poll, I even picked
"Lost Chronicles" as their best instrumental piece. But at times I
still have to consciously disregard the drum work on that album in
order to enjoy listening to it.
Steve
More information about the boc-l
mailing list