Censorship goes local

M Holmes fofp at HOLYROOD.ED.AC.UK
Fri Nov 16 07:06:18 EST 2007


Arjan Hulsebos writes:

> But still there's a difference between "Jesus is a cunt" and "<some person's
> name> is a cunt". And FoS shouldn't allow me to say "Mike Holmes is a
> murderer", even in the case you're not offended by it.

I disagree. You should be able to say it. If I can prove it has caused
me damage, then I should be able to require you to either prove the
statement true, or compensate me for the damage caused.

Basically there are two solutions to false witness:

1) Remove freedom of speech.

2) Keep freedom of speech, but make people legally responsible for the
consequences of their exercise of it.

FoFP



More information about the boc-l mailing list